zzdcar
Home
/
Reviews
/
Racing
/
Ex-F1 Doctor Claims FIA Tried To Have Him Fired Over Blog Posts
Ex-F1 Doctor Claims FIA Tried To Have Him Fired Over Blog Posts-April 2024
2024-02-19 EST 22:11:47

Dr. Gary Hartstein's blog, A Former F1 Doc Writes, is an excellent resource for anyone interested in motorsports and medicine. Unfortunately, FIA Institute President Gérard Saillant that these posts violated Hartstein's contract with his current day job at the University Hospital of Liège.

Full disclosure: we've Hartstein's posts here several times for their insight into what the terminology used in reports of larger medical incidents really means.

Saillant took over for Professor Sid Watkins after Watkins' retirement in 2011, working with Hartstein on the medical team that accompanies each Formula One race weekend. Saillant reportedly fired Hartstein via email when Hartstein was let go in 2012, leaving Hartstein with the whole situation.

Per Hartstein's post about this earlier, Saillant paid the dean of the medical faculty over the University of Liège a visit with a collection of blog posts and at least one email from Corinna Schumacher that Hartstein never received due to a typo in the email address. The reason for the visit was to see if Hartstein's blog violated his contract at work.

Hartstein as been working at the University Hospital of Liège for twenty-five years, even during his tenure as a FIA Medical Delegate for F1. This is the job that pays Hartstein's day-to-day bills, and Hartstein is livid (albeit unsurprised) that Saillant would do such a petty thing behind his back.

As a knowledgeable but outside voice, Saillant is clearly in the wrong about this, and Hartstein took him to task on his blog:

Let's just look at the facts, ok?

1) This blog makes no claim to represent the opinions of anyone other than myself. And while my bio may mention that I studied and work at the University Hospital of Liège, no other mention is made of this fact. All blog-related activity, then, is part of my personal life. Period.

2) Doctor-patient confidentiality is never violated, for two pretty good reasons. First of all, Michael is not and (other than the stuff that came up over 15 years of F1) never has been my patient. Second, I make perfectly clear that NONE of what I wrote in the days, weeks, and months following Michael's accident was based on anything other than conjecture and experience.

3) When opinions are expressed, they are clearly identified as such, and are never presented with an intent to harm. This intent is abundantly clear, and is even explained on numerous occasions.

For fans, Hartstein does a tremendous service by interpreting complicated medical news into terms that are understandable to the everyday person. While much of the media focuses on sensational headlines, Hartstein quickly cuts through the hyperbole and rumor to get down to the known facts that have been released and whether those are as worrying as the media would have you believe.

For the FIA not to understand the blog's importance to fans shows just how out of touch and off-base they are. While he references several of the patients he worked with in Formula One, he's always very tactful to stick to information that's been released to the media in his posts.

FIA President Jean Todt was also named in the open letter, as Hartstein implies that Saillant was working in some official capacity to shutter the blog.

The fact that none of these allegations were brought to Hartstein's attention before Saillant met with the dean is slimy and underhanded. According to Hartstein, they're legally questionable as well.

Hartstein has handed over the full dossier that Saillant collected on him to his attorney and ended his open letter with stern advice for the FIA:

Word to the wise?

Shut up, back off, and watch out.

The full text of Dr. Gary Hartstein's letter to Prof. Gérard Saillant and Jean Todt can be found , and it's definitely worth a read to understand precisely what people mean when they accuse the FIA of working in secret, and not for the best interests of the sport they purport to represent.

Comments
Welcome to zzdcar comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Racing
Local Businesses Want Compensation After Allegedly Losing Money During Formula 1 Las Vegas Grand Prix
Local Businesses Want Compensation After Allegedly Losing Money During Formula 1 Las Vegas Grand Prix
If you listen to Formula 1 or local officials from Las Vegas and Clark County, you’d probably think November’s inaugural Las Vegas Grand Prix was a success. Some sources estimated that the city of Las Vegas made over $1 billion in revenue from the event — but there were...
Apr 20, 2025
Race Team Would Rather Create A Fake AI Woman Rather Than Hire A Real One
Race Team Would Rather Create A Fake AI Woman Rather Than Hire A Real One
In another unsurprising example of motorsport’s inhospitable mindset toward hiring competent women, the Racing team has announced a new partnership with Ava Rose, a literal , who will... engage with fans? Share knowledge about technology? “Navigate the cutting edge of innovation to create positive change” (whatever that means)? I...
Apr 20, 2025
Get Ready To Spend All Your Money On Retro Formula 1 Merch
Get Ready To Spend All Your Money On Retro Formula 1 Merch
Fellow nerds, get ready to open your wallets, because I’ve found what may be the greatest store of all time. With designs from Formula 1 teams like , you’re sure to find something that fits your particular nostalgic niche. I’d like to introduce you to Racing Retro. I first...
Apr 20, 2025
You've Probably Never Heard Of The Coolest Canadian Car Ever Built
You've Probably Never Heard Of The Coolest Canadian Car Ever Built
Name a car from the early 1960s built by a famed racing driver with curvy, lightweight aluminum bodywork, a big American engine, and a reputation for being unruly and fast as all hell. Your first thought was probably the famed Shelby Cobra, did you know there was a who...
Apr 20, 2025
Listen To In-Car Audio From Race Cars While You Work
Listen To In-Car Audio From Race Cars While You Work
If you follow racing in the U.S., you probably already know about the . Most of the episodes are too much of a distraction to put on as background noise while you work, but a couple of recent entries in his series have been working incredibly well for me....
Apr 20, 2025
After Delivering 8 Seasons At The Back Of The Grid, Haas F1 Team Dumps Guenther Steiner
After Delivering 8 Seasons At The Back Of The Grid, Haas F1 Team Dumps Guenther Steiner
The partially North Carolina-based squad has determined that after , it needs to mix things up a little. The team’s firebrand has been following an abysmal 2023 season which saw the team score just four points-paying finishes. The team’s , where scored a fourth-place finish, but that season too...
Apr 20, 2025
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.zzdcar.com All Rights Reserved