zzdcar
Home
/
Reviews
/
Tech
/
New Jersey Bill Takes a Soft Stand Against In-Car Subscriptions
New Jersey Bill Takes a Soft Stand Against In-Car Subscriptions-April 2024
2024-02-19 EST 22:10:24

Image for article titled New Jersey Bill Takes a Soft Stand Against In-Car Subscriptions

In-car subscriptions are one of those impending modern calamities that unite everyone in disgust. Nobody who isn’t a C-suite executive at at automaker or one of their suppliers . It should be the job of our elected officials to shield us from the erosion of our rights as consumers (, but that’s a whole other story). Wouldn’t you know, my home state of New Jersey might just take a stand. Jersey!

introduced last month by NJ Assemblyman Paul Moriarty (D - Camden and Gloucester) intends to strengthen the state’s Consumer Fraud Act by making it illegal for automakers to impose subscriptions for safety and convenience features, if the components that enable them are already pre-installed in the vehicle. You know, like and for luxuries like heated seats and high-beam assist.

There is one major caveat to Moriarty’s bill , which is that it makes provisions for features that function “with ongoing expense to the dealer, manufacturer, or any third-party service provider.” If the particular add-on is a “live” service, or something that requires active investment or development from somebody, then a subscription model would be permitted.

Image for article titled New Jersey Bill Takes a Soft Stand Against In-Car Subscriptions

This is understandable on some level, because features like semi-autonomous driving are continuously honed, and those revisions are distributed regularly via over-the-air updates in lots of cases. You could make a similar case for satellite radio, or in-car Wi-Fi. But there are sure to be gray areas, too, where automakers claim to be continually investing in services that are pretty much one-and-done jobs. Like, say, what three years ago, and .

Here’s the beautiful thing about CarPlay and Android Auto — they live on your phone, completely. Yes, there is a chipset inside your car that allows your smartphone to hand off iOS or Android to the infotainment stack, but all the processing is actually done on device. Back in 2019, though, that Apple could conceivablyupdate iOS in a way that causes glitches with how the automaker’s ConnectedDrive platform interfaces with CarPlay, and that it would fall on BMW software engineers to rectify those hiccups.

Of course, bugs in consumer electronics are typically addressed in software updates, which — as anyone who has ever used a phone, tablet or PC will tell you — are free and guaranteed for at least a good few years after you buy the product. And when the device in question reaches end-of-life status, you don’t suddenly have to pay a recurring fee to keep using it. If all these car companies , they ought to bear the same responsibilities.

BMW’s stance was a flimsy cop out for greed. But it was also the sort of defense that might just fly, if NJ lawmakers don’t carefully check automakers for exploiting the “ongoing expense” loophole. For what it’s worth, I don’t appear to be telling the bill’s backers something they don’t already know. A summary prepared by law firm pretty much scoped this, pertinent portion bolded by yours truly:

If passed, Assembly Bill 4519, introduced on September 22, 2022, by Representative Paul Moriarty, would define a violation of the act as an unlawful practice. That would impose a civil penalty of $10,000 for a first violation and $20,000 for subsequent violations. Of significant concern for manufacturers and dealers is that, while not expressly mentioned in the bill or drafter’s statement, the private right of action and other remedies (including treble damages) available under New Jersey’s Consumer Fraud Act would also apply. Thus, this bill has the potential to significantly impact both local auto dealer franchisees and global automakers whose vehicles are sold to New Jersey residents.

At the very least, “dumb” features like automatic high beams and seat heating and cooling should fall under the target, which is better than nothing.

If the law does pass, it’ll be interesting to see if and how automakers approach sales in the state a little differently, like how Subaru “addressed” Massachusetts’ Right to Repair and telematics legislation by . Maybe my fellow New Jerseyan Andy Kalmowitz will have to buy his in New York or Pennsylvania if he wants the ability to change his sedan’s fake engine noises.

It’s also important to note that No. 4519 exclusively takes aim at subscriptions, defined as “recurring payment, including, but not limited to, a weekly, monthly, or annual payment.” One-time, post-sale charges would still be legal. In other words, there’d be nothing stopping a dealer from selling you a car with butt-warming coils, but only letting you turn them on once you’ve paid a hefty lump sum — maybe equaling the price of a multi-year subscription, special for Jersey drivers. This could play out so many ways, and the bill could probably use some fine tuning before it’s voted on. It’s a start, I suppose.

Comments
Welcome to zzdcar comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Tech
GM Says It's Dropping Apple CarPlay And Android Auto Because They're Unsafe (Update)
GM Says It's Dropping Apple CarPlay And Android Auto Because They're Unsafe (Update)
GM is still dealing with the fallout of its decision to drop Apple CarPlay and Android Auto in favor of developing its own in-house system. In the last eight months, the company has had to deal with while still maintaining its in-house system will be “.” Since neither of...
Apr 23, 2025
Biden’s First EV Charging Station Goes Online After $7.5 Billion In American EV Investments
Biden’s First EV Charging Station Goes Online After $7.5 Billion In American EV Investments
Despite in investments for the development of in the , not a single charging station had gone live thanks to — until now. The first EV charger paid for by Biden’s Bipartisan deal has come online in Ohio, according to , which marks the operational start of what the...
Apr 23, 2025
Danish Investors Dump Tesla Shares After Elon Musk Calls Strikes In Sweden 'Insane'
Danish Investors Dump Tesla Shares After Elon Musk Calls Strikes In Sweden 'Insane'
Danish pension fund PensionDanmark is dumping all of its stock and putting the U.S. EV maker on its exclusion list of the companies it chooses to invest in – or not. The fund is selling all of its shares due to Elon Musk’s refusal to enter into labor agreements...
Apr 23, 2025
Volkswagen EVs Can Now Power Your House For Two Days (Update)
Volkswagen EVs Can Now Power Your House For Two Days (Update)
Experts have said that one of the ways to speed up EV adoption is for them to support . The ability for owners to power their house off their car or from the grid is vital. Just nine EVs on the market currently support bidirectional charging, but now VW...
Apr 23, 2025
Costco Will Sell The Chevy Blazer EV At A Discount To Go With Your Rotisserie Chicken
Costco Will Sell The Chevy Blazer EV At A Discount To Go With Your Rotisserie Chicken
knows that you keep coming back for the and Kirkland brand, but you can now also buy a cheaper at your local warehouse. Chevy notified its dealers that members are eligible for a $1,000 rebate on the through January 2, according to . The discount is part of ,...
Apr 23, 2025
Truck Fans Would Rather Wait For A Toyota Tacoma EV Than Buy A F-150 Lightning Or Cybertruck
Truck Fans Would Rather Wait For A Toyota Tacoma EV Than Buy A F-150 Lightning Or Cybertruck
fans are already cooling on despite more options on the market and news of upcoming models from the likes of Chevy and Ram. The and have yet to be released, while the has recently joined the and for sale in the U.S. And, yet, all of these current and...
Apr 23, 2025
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.zzdcar.com All Rights Reserved