zzdcar
Home
/
Reviews
/
Buying
/
Deadly Tesla Crash Suspected Of Being Caused By Autopilot Was Apparently A Result Of Human Error
Deadly Tesla Crash Suspected Of Being Caused By Autopilot Was Apparently A Result Of Human Error-October 2024
2024-02-19 EST 22:09:28

Image for article titled Deadly Tesla Crash Suspected Of Being Caused By Autopilot Was Apparently A Result Of Human Error

Back in April, resulting in two deaths and a four-hour fire. When first responders got to the car, they found an empty driver’s seat — one occupant in the passenger seat, one in the rear, but no one behind the wheel. Now, months later, it seems the National Transportation Safety Board has come to a conclusion about how this all happened.

When news first broke of the fatal accident, many — including Jalopnik — were quick to speculate that Autopilot had a hand in the collision. It’s a reasonable thing to suspect, given that the vehicle had apparently been found without a driver behind the wheel: Did a car, , manage to drive itself into a tree in a tech demo gone wrong?

Image for article titled Deadly Tesla Crash Suspected Of Being Caused By Autopilot Was Apparently A Result Of Human Error

According to the NTSB, :

The crash trip originated at the owner’s residence near the end of a cul-de-sac. Footage from the owner’s home security camera shows the owner entering the car’s driver’s seat and the passenger entering the front passenger seat. The car leaves and travels about 550 feet before departing the road on a curve, driving over the curb, and hitting a drainage culvert, a raised manhole, and a tree.

In addition to the footage, analysis of the steering wheel pointed to it being subjected to an impact, presumably from a driver. Once again :

A postcrash inspection of the car showed that the steering wheel was damaged and deformed. The steering wheel was removed and transported to the NTSB Materials Laboratory for detailed examination. Initial results indicate that although some damage was caused by the intense heat of the postcrash fire, deformation along the top and left side of the steering wheel’s outer rim, as shown in figure 3, was due to an impact.

The Tesla’s steering wheel was pushed 3.5" back in the impact

Note that the NTSB does not discuss the vehicle’s airbags beyond stating in its report that it was evaluating a fire-damaged “restraint control module,” which could provide insight into the Tesla’s airbag deployment during the crash.

The NTSB specifically mentions Autopilot in its report, implying that the function was almost certainly not in use at the time of the crash:

The vehicle was equipped with Autopilot, Tesla’s advanced driver assistance system. Using Autopilot requires both the Traffic Aware Cruise Control and the Autosteer systems to be engaged.[2] NTSB tests of an exemplar car at the crash location showed that Traffic Aware Cruise Control could be engaged but that Autosteer was not available on that part of the road.

Instead of anything autonomous, it seems the Tesla’s owner wanted to demonstrate a different EV perk to their passenger: speed. The NTSB’s analysis of data recorded by the car shows heavy acceleration and speeds more than double the limit on the cul-de-sac:

The data also indicate that the driver was applying the accelerator in the time leading up to the crash; application of the accelerator pedal was found to be as high as 98.8 percent. The highest speed recorded by the EDR in the 5 seconds leading up to the crash was 67 mph.

NTSB notes that “No speed limit sign​s were posted in the crash area, but the maximum speed limit for the road was 30 mph.”

Hammock Dunes Place, the road where the crash occurred

While NTSB’s findings point towards the driver being at fault, there’s no discussion in the investigation update as to why neither occupant of the car was found in the driver’s seat. speculated that the driver’s door may have been damaged in the collision, and that the driver crawled to the back in search of an exit, but nothing has been officially confirmed. It wouldn’t be the first time in a fatal collision.

After all the discussion about Autopilot, and the , the story of this crash appears to be a classic tale: too much horsepower in the hands of a driver who couldn’t keep hold of the reins. But while any fast car can run off-course, its inertia overpowering its tires’ grip, not every car can in the event of a crash. Teslas may score well in crash-safety tests, and carry no flammable gasoline, but many drivers are unprepared for the cars’ instant and considerable torque — the thrills may be high, but so are the risks.

This story has been updated with a note about airbag deployment

Comments
Welcome to zzdcar comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Buying
Which One Of You Suckers Is Going To Pay Over $32,000 For A 25-Year-Old Toyota 4Runner
Which One Of You Suckers Is Going To Pay Over $32,000 For A 25-Year-Old Toyota 4Runner
The (and Tacoma) have a death grip on used values. It’s been this way for years. Go ahead, go try and buy any TRD trim that’s a couple of years old; it’ll cost you as much as a new one — not that you could buy a new one...
Oct 26, 2024
At $8,600, Would You Go Topless In This 1994 Cadillac Eldorado?
At $8,600, Would You Go Topless In This 1994 Cadillac Eldorado?
The seller of today’s Caddy claims they should be selling it at auction but says who’s got time for that? Let’s see if we have the time for this custom convertible at its non-auction price. Many of you agreed that the $950 asked for yesterday’s was “chump change.” Even...
Oct 26, 2024
At $5,900, Is This 1984 Nissan 720 4X4 A Solid Deal?
At $5,900, Is This 1984 Nissan 720 4X4 A Solid Deal?
According to its seller, today’s Nissan 4X4 shows “pride of ownership.” Let’s see if it would take swallowing one’s pride to pay its asking price. Opinions were split on how well the design of yesterday’s has held up over the years. Some of you commented that the design still...
Oct 26, 2024
Someone Willingly Paid $16,000 For A Maserati Ghibli On Cars & Bids. Don’t Make The Same Mistake
Someone Willingly Paid $16,000 For A Maserati Ghibli On Cars & Bids. Don’t Make The Same Mistake
Let’s cut right to the chase: buying a is not a good idea unless you have deep enough pockets for the upkeep. For those not in the know, they’re sirens. They draw you in with their premium Italian image and sweet songs of and then go in for the...
Oct 26, 2024
At $18,500, Would You Lean Toward Buying This 2022 Ford Mustang?
At $18,500, Would You Lean Toward Buying This 2022 Ford Mustang?
Today’s Mustang is being sold by a towing yard, which means it’s probably a lien sale. Let’s see if this clean title convertible is priced to put a new buyer on the hook. The general consensus on last Friday’s was that it would be the perfect car for someone...
Oct 26, 2024
At $950, Would You Go All-In On This 1984 Plymouth Colt GTS Turbo Project?
At $950, Would You Go All-In On This 1984 Plymouth Colt GTS Turbo Project?
One of the calling cards of today’s Plymouth Colt is its “Twin Stick” overdrive gear change, which gives the car eight speeds going forward and two in reverse. Let’s see if this project car has anything else to offer. Just as Goldilocks discovered when appropriating Papa Bear’s lifestyle and...
Oct 26, 2024
Copyright 2023-2024 - www.zzdcar.com All Rights Reserved