zzdcar
Home
/
Reviews
/
Buying
/
Edmunds Files Lawsuit Over Fake Dealership Review Comments
Edmunds Files Lawsuit Over Fake Dealership Review Comments-October 2024
2024-02-19 EST 22:10:08

, one of the web's leading resources for car-buying research and , filed a lawsuit against a Texas company it says registered more than 2,200 fake online profiles that submitted reviews of car dealerships. Edmunds isn't happy about it, and now they're going to court.

The lawsuit accuses Friendswood, Texas-based , who bill themselves as an "online reputation company," of violating their terms of service, trademark infringement, fraud, false advertising and other acts.

Edmunds' lawsuit claims that Humankind registered scores of fake member accounts on their site that were used to create content designed to sway users' opinions of car dealers.

Apparently, this is Humankind's whole business model. The lawsuit alleges that Humankind operates websites like , which, according to , charge $25 and up a month to post reviews at what it calls “supported sites" such as Yelp, Google Plus, FourSquare, CitySearch, Cars.com, and now Edmunds.com. They say that they use the logos of these companies without their consent, hence the trademark violation.

Edmunds says they found the fake reviews because they conduct thorough searches of every dealer review submitted to their site. (If they're anything like the "Ingrid's story is amazing, but I made $2,700 working from home last month and bought a 1992 Subaru Legacy" ones we get, they're pretty easy to spot.)

Perhaps the most damning accusation is that Edmunds claims Humankind and GlowingReviews :

In general, the review sites state that you must be posting for yourself and not for someone else. So in these cases the answer would be yes. That said, if you take the time to actually read the TOS you'll see that it's very easy to break something.

But this really begs looking back at the big picture. Take SEO as an example. Every link that you build to your site, every fiverr gig that you buy, every article you publish on EZine Articles is violating Google TOS. In fact, anything you do to help improve your site's ranking violates Google terms.

Every business plays in this grey area and this service just lets you do it much more efficiently.

Here's what Edmunds said to about that:

“Given the explicit acknowledgement that they were breaking our terms of service, we felt like we had to skip the usual step of filing a cease-and-desist order,” said Ken Levin, senior executive vice president and general counsel at Edmunds.com, explaining why the company saw it necessary to file for an injunction ordering Humankind to stop posting reviews at Edmunds’ site. “[A cease-and-desist request] probably just wouldn’t be effective. In all likelihood, the response to that is ‘OK, we’ll stop.’ And then they’d start doing it again a little later.”

Exact damages sought by Edmunds are not specified in the lawsuit.

The TIME story goes much deeper into Humankind and their website. Contacted by the news site, a spokesman for Yelp said he was unaware of these specific comments on their site, but said they're hardly the only company doing this, and that they're currently working to crack down on fake reviews.

I can't wait to see how this one plays out in court. It could have a lasting impact on these attempts to feed fake reviews onto websites.

Have you ever seen fake-looking review comments at Edmunds?

Comments
Welcome to zzdcar comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Buying
Someone Willingly Paid $16,000 For A Maserati Ghibli On Cars & Bids. Don’t Make The Same Mistake
Someone Willingly Paid $16,000 For A Maserati Ghibli On Cars & Bids. Don’t Make The Same Mistake
Let’s cut right to the chase: buying a is not a good idea unless you have deep enough pockets for the upkeep. For those not in the know, they’re sirens. They draw you in with their premium Italian image and sweet songs of and then go in for the...
Oct 26, 2024
Which One Of You Suckers Is Going To Pay Over $32,000 For A 25-Year-Old Toyota 4Runner
Which One Of You Suckers Is Going To Pay Over $32,000 For A 25-Year-Old Toyota 4Runner
The (and Tacoma) have a death grip on used values. It’s been this way for years. Go ahead, go try and buy any TRD trim that’s a couple of years old; it’ll cost you as much as a new one — not that you could buy a new one...
Oct 26, 2024
At $5,900, Is This 1984 Nissan 720 4X4 A Solid Deal?
At $5,900, Is This 1984 Nissan 720 4X4 A Solid Deal?
According to its seller, today’s Nissan 4X4 shows “pride of ownership.” Let’s see if it would take swallowing one’s pride to pay its asking price. Opinions were split on how well the design of yesterday’s has held up over the years. Some of you commented that the design still...
Oct 26, 2024
At $950, Would You Go All-In On This 1984 Plymouth Colt GTS Turbo Project?
At $950, Would You Go All-In On This 1984 Plymouth Colt GTS Turbo Project?
One of the calling cards of today’s Plymouth Colt is its “Twin Stick” overdrive gear change, which gives the car eight speeds going forward and two in reverse. Let’s see if this project car has anything else to offer. Just as Goldilocks discovered when appropriating Papa Bear’s lifestyle and...
Oct 26, 2024
At $18,500, Would You Lean Toward Buying This 2022 Ford Mustang?
At $18,500, Would You Lean Toward Buying This 2022 Ford Mustang?
Today’s Mustang is being sold by a towing yard, which means it’s probably a lien sale. Let’s see if this clean title convertible is priced to put a new buyer on the hook. The general consensus on last Friday’s was that it would be the perfect car for someone...
Oct 26, 2024
At $8,600, Would You Go Topless In This 1994 Cadillac Eldorado?
At $8,600, Would You Go Topless In This 1994 Cadillac Eldorado?
The seller of today’s Caddy claims they should be selling it at auction but says who’s got time for that? Let’s see if we have the time for this custom convertible at its non-auction price. Many of you agreed that the $950 asked for yesterday’s was “chump change.” Even...
Oct 26, 2024
Copyright 2023-2024 - www.zzdcar.com All Rights Reserved