zzdcar
Home
/
Reviews
/
Buying
/
Judge Rules GM Wasn’t Deceptive With Its Destination Charges
Judge Rules GM Wasn’t Deceptive With Its Destination Charges-November 2024
2024-02-19 EST 22:09:17

2021 Chevrolet Equinox

Destination charges have in the auto industry. Some customers aren’t too happy about it, especially the fact that automakers may be making a profit off of these charges that the companies often try to separate from the vehicle’s price. reports that a class action lawsuit against GM over customer concerns about GM making a profit over destination charges has been dismissed.

The in the Southern District of California and consisted of two plaintiffs, Robert Romoff from California and Joe Siciliano from New Jersey. Romoff purchased a 2021 Chevy Equinox and paid a $1,195 destination charge while Sicilino paid just $995 on his 2021 Cadillac Escalade. The said that the destination charge is “ generally understood in the automotive industry to reflect the manufacturer’s average cost of delivering one of its vehicles to a dealership. Line items are intended to inform consumers of the reason they are being charged.”

But the plaintiffs claim that they were unaware that GM made a profit from the charges.

“For that reason, consumers do not generally expect line-item costs to include hidden profit.”

However, U.S. District Judge William Hayes disagreed and dismissed the case. He argued that most consumers wouldn’t bat an eye at learning that the price of something they purchased resulted in a profit for the company that makes it. He then quoted the which requires that automakers disclose how much they make dealers pay them for delivery. He continued, arguing that the rule “no more suggests the absence of profit than the term ‘Destination Charge.’ Judges from the ninth and 10th circuit court of appeals agreed with him, weirdly saying that GM charges dealers and not consumers for destination charges. From:

“There is no allegation that GM charged the dealers a lesser amount than is represented to consumers, enabling the dealer to earn a secret profit from consumers,” the judges wrote in their Jan. 30 decision.

Disagreeing with the judgment, Romoff and Siciliano are appealing. They claim Hayes drew a conclusion about what most consumers would think too early in the proceedings and that he had a narrow view of what constitutes common sense in something like this. They also claim that Hayes ignored a California Court of Appeals case that a business charging more than what it actually cost for a service without customers being aware of it may be misleading.

Comments
Welcome to zzdcar comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Buying
VW Confirms US-Built ID.4 Will Be Eligible for the $7,500 Federal Tax Credit
VW Confirms US-Built ID.4 Will Be Eligible for the $7,500 Federal Tax Credit
Automakers have been freaking out since the Biden administration reworked how the to disqualify foreign-built EVs. See, EVs still haven’t really hit price parity with internal combustion vehicles, so using that tax credit as a carrot to bring buyers other than eco-warriors and early adopters into the fold was...
Nov 17, 2026
Nissan Lowers Leaf Lease Price After New EV Tax Credit Rules
Nissan Lowers Leaf Lease Price After New EV Tax Credit Rules
Between sagging sales and being cut off from the , had to do something to breathe a little bit of life into its . As of April 18th, meant could no longer take advantage of the discount. According to , in order to help combat that and the rising...
Nov 17, 2026
At $9,995, Is This 2000 Mazda MX-5 Miata an Acceptable Answer?
At $9,995, Is This 2000 Mazda MX-5 Miata an Acceptable Answer?
The seller of today’s Mazda MX-5 wants the car gone by tomorrow as they have found another car to buy and are in need of the cash. Let’s see if this Miata’s price will help them move the metal. We looked yesterday at a rare saffron-hued that was offered...
Nov 17, 2026
The 2023 Honda Civic Type R Is Here to Play With Record-Setting Nürburgring Lap
The 2023 Honda Civic Type R Is Here to Play With Record-Setting Nürburgring Lap
Five years ago, Honda . That car ran a 7:43.8, which stood untested for a year before with its Megane RS Trophy-R and a 7:40.1 time. Now, Honda’s taken the throne back in , with a 7:44.881 lap. Wait, what? Yes, you read that right: The new record-setting lap...
Nov 17, 2026
I'm a College Kid Looking for a Practical and Fuel Efficient Ride! What Car Should I Buy?
I'm a College Kid Looking for a Practical and Fuel Efficient Ride! What Car Should I Buy?
Dylan goes to college in Montana and his 2008 Ford Taurus is too old and not great on gas. He wants something affordable with some level of practicality, better fuel efficiency, and can handle winter weather. What car should he buy? (Welcome back to ? Where we give real...
Nov 17, 2026
At $6,000, Is This ‘Saffron’ 1998 Volvo V70R Worth Your Gold?
At $6,000, Is This ‘Saffron’ 1998 Volvo V70R Worth Your Gold?
Coming in at the tail end of a movie can be frustrating. Today’s V70R isn’t quite at the tail end of its useful life, and if the price is right, it may be worth riding into the sunset. There’s a myth that Benjamin Franklin lobbied for the turkey to...
Nov 17, 2026
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.zzdcar.com All Rights Reserved